Dina Merrill House: History, Architecture & Design

Dina Merrill House represents a significant architectural landmark. Reverend Alfred Battell commissioned the building of Dina Merrill House in the late 19th century. Architectural elements of Dina Merrill House showcase Second Empire style, reflecting the aesthetic preferences of its time. Graciela design contributes to the house’s unique charm and character.

Picture this: a sprawling estate, bathed in the golden light of a Hamptons sunset. We’re not talking about just any house; we’re talking about the Dina Merrill House, a true Southampton landmark that whispers tales of old money, Hollywood glamour, and enough social intrigue to fill a season of your favorite period drama.

Now, before you conjure images of stuffy drawing rooms and monocled millionaires, let me assure you, this story is anything but boring. The Dina Merrill House, located at the prestigious address of 95 Coopers Neck Lane, isn’t just a building; it’s a living, breathing monument to a bygone era, a place where fortunes were made, and legends were born.

This isn’t just about bricks and mortar, folks. It’s about the fascinating individuals who graced its halls: the dazzling Dina Merrill herself, the financial titan E.F. Hutton, and the cereal heiress with a heart of gold, Marjorie Merriweather Post. Intrigued? You should be! This house has seen it all, from Gilded Age extravagance to star-studded soirees. Get ready to take a peek inside!

Hutton Manor: The Genesis of a Gilded Age Estate

So, let’s rewind the clock and uncover the story of how this Southampton stunner, now known as the Dina Merrill House, began its journey. Back in the day, it wasn’t sipping tea with socialites; it was being born as Hutton Manor. Think of it as the estate’s cool, vintage nickname.

The mastermind behind this initial creation? A chap named Hugh Chisholm. Now, Hugh wasn’t just building a house; he was building a dream. He had a vision, a grand plan for a property that would be the envy of all. Picture him, sketching out ideas, imagining lavish parties, and planning where to plant the prize-winning roses. This was his canvas, and he was ready to create a masterpiece.

Speaking of masterpieces, the architectural style of Hutton Manor is a nod to the opulent Gilded Age. We’re talking ornate details, sweeping verandas, and an overall vibe of understated elegance (okay, maybe not so understated!). It’s the kind of place where you half-expect Jay Gatsby to pop out from behind a pillar, offering you a cocktail.

And who do we thank for turning Hugh Chisholm’s vision into a reality? The talented Charles E. Birge, the architect extraordinaire behind the initial design. Birge wasn’t just drawing up blueprints; he was crafting an icon. He understood the language of the Gilded Age, translating it into a building that would stand the test of time. Think of him as the OG house whisperer.

Dina Merrill: Actress, Socialite, and the House’s Namesake

Let’s talk about the real star of our show, the woman who gave the Dina Merrill House its name and a whole lot of its sparkle! Dina Merrill wasn’t just any socialite; she was a force of nature, a woman who juggled Hollywood glamour, high society, and serious business savvy with the kind of effortless charm that makes you wonder if she had a secret cloning machine.

Dina wasn’t just a pretty face; she was a talented actress who held her own alongside some of Hollywood’s biggest names. Think of her “Hollywood Connection” as a golden thread weaving through her life. She graced the silver screen in films like Operation Petticoat with Cary Grant, Butterfield 8 alongside Elizabeth Taylor, and The Sundowners with Robert Mitchum. She proved she was more than just a socialite dabbling in acting; she was a genuine performer who could command attention. Imagine the stories she must have had from those sets, the parties, the premieres… it’s enough to make any Hollywood history buff swoon!

But wait, there’s more! Dina wasn’t content with just conquering Hollywood. She was a trailblazing businesswoman and a dedicated philanthropist. She sat on numerous boards, championed causes she believed in, and even started her own cosmetics company. Talk about a multi-hyphenate! And, of course, we can’t forget her two marriages. First, to actor Clifford Robertson, a union that brought together two Hollywood stars, and later to Ted Hartley, who remained her husband until her death. Both men played a significant role in her life, undoubtedly influencing her time at the iconic house and adding to its rich tapestry of stories.

In short, Dina Merrill was a true original – a woman who defied easy labels and lived life on her own terms. She was an icon, a legend, and the perfect namesake for a house as grand and fascinating as she was. The Dina Merrill House wasn’t just a building; it was a stage for her remarkable life, and that’s something worth celebrating.

F. Hutton and Marjorie Merriweather Post: Titans of Finance and Industry

E.F. Hutton, now there’s a name that screams Wall Street, doesn’t it? Forget the whispers – this guy was shouting money from the rooftops! As a financier and co-founder of E.F. Hutton & Co., he wasn’t just playing the stock market; he was practically conducting it. Picture him in a room full of suits, everyone hanging on his every word because, let’s be honest, his words often turned into fortunes. His influence? Let’s just say it was titanic. He wasn’t directly associated with Dina Merrill House, but his connection is a marriage between Dina Merrill and Clifford Robertson.

And then we have Marjorie Merriweather Post, a name that conjures images of glamour, wealth, and a serious cereal empire. Yes, you heard that right, cereal! Marjorie inherited the Post Cereal Company (which later became General Foods) from her father and turned it into a household name. But she wasn’t just about breakfast; Marjorie was a social icon, a philanthropist, and a woman who knew how to live large. Her societal impact was undeniable, shaping the landscape of high society and leaving a lasting legacy of generosity. Similar to E.F. Hutton, Marjorie Merriweather Post wasn’t directly associated with Dina Merrill House but their connection can be found in Marjorie Merriweather Post daughter married E.F Hutton.

Now, you might be wondering, how do these figures tie into the Dina Merrill House? While neither E.F. Hutton nor Marjorie Merriweather Post directly owned or resided at the estate, their connections run through the intertwining webs of high society and family ties. They represent the era, the affluence, and the interconnectedness of the elite circles that the Dina Merrill House became a part of. It’s like a historical Venn diagram, where finance, industry, and social prominence overlap to create a fascinating backstory to this iconic property. It’s a story about how wealth, influence, and a good bowl of cereal can shape history, one mansion at a time.

A Hub of High Society: Life at the Dina Merrill House

Imagine this: stepping into a world where glamour wasn’t just for the movies, but an everyday affair. That’s precisely what life was like at the Dina Merrill House. It wasn’t just a home; it was a buzzing social beehive, a place where the who’s who of the Social Register gathered to see and be seen. This wasn’t your average cocktail party; we’re talking galas, fundraisers, and sophisticated soirees under the stars! The Dina Merrill House became synonymous with elegance and a vibrant social scene, solidifying its place in the Upper Echelon of society.

What kind of shindigs are we talking about? Think lavish garden parties with guests in their finest attire, charity balls that sparkled with Diamonds and Champagne, and intimate dinners where the Future of the World was being discussed over plates of the most exquisite cuisine. The Dina Merrill House played host to a continuous stream of notable figures, each event carefully curated to foster connection and celebration.

But it wasn’t all champagne and caviar, friends. Dina Merrill and her family were deeply committed to philanthropy. The house often served as a backdrop for charitable events, raising funds and awareness for causes close to their hearts. From supporting the arts to advancing medical research, the Merrill family used their influence and resources to make a tangible difference. They really put the ‘giving’ in giving back, proving that high society could also have a heart of gold. It wasn’t just a pretty place; it was a place that made a difference.

The Allure of The Hamptons: Location, Location, Location

Ah, The Hamptons! Just the name conjures images of sun-kissed beaches, clinking champagne glasses, and sprawling estates. But what is it about this string of towns on Long Island that makes it such a magnet for the rich and fabulous? Well, it’s not just the proximity to New York City, though that certainly helps. The Hamptons, especially Southampton, offer a unique blend of old-world charm and modern luxury that’s hard to resist.

Southampton, in particular, has always held a special allure. It’s the oldest English settlement in New York, oozing with history and a sense of understated elegance. Think less flashy, more quietly confident. This is where families have summered for generations, building legacies and creating memories that last a lifetime. And what’s a key ingredient for this allure, you ask? Location, location, location!

Coopers Neck Lane: A Street with a Pedigree

Now, let’s zoom in on Coopers Neck Lane. This isn’t just any street; it’s a Southampton address that speaks volumes. It’s like saying you have a box seat at the opera, or a table at the restaurant. Coopers Neck Lane is where you find some of the most stunning estates, homes that whisper tales of fortunes made and lives well-lived. It’s a prestigious address synonymous with exclusivity and a certain level of sophistication.

Living on Coopers Neck Lane isn’t just about having a beautiful house; it’s about belonging to a community of like-minded individuals who value privacy, beauty, and a certain understated elegance. It’s no wonder that properties here are highly sought after and rarely come on the market. This street has a certain magic!

A Landscape of Dreams

But it’s not just the exclusive address; it’s also the breathtaking surroundings that make the Dina Merrill House (and others on Coopers Neck Lane) so special. Imagine rolling lawns stretching towards the ocean, ancient trees providing shade and privacy, and the gentle scent of salt air wafting through the windows. The Hamptons landscape is a masterpiece of nature, carefully curated over decades.

The setting surrounding the house is a symphony of natural beauty. Think lush gardens bursting with color, manicured lawns perfect for croquet, and maybe even a glimpse of the ocean sparkling in the distance. It’s a place where you can escape the hustle and bustle of city life and reconnect with nature, all while living in the lap of luxury. It’s this incredible combination of location and natural beauty that makes The Hamptons, and Coopers Neck Lane in particular, such a desirable place to call home, even if only for the summer!

From Hutton Manor to the Dina Merrill House: Tracing the Estate’s History

Ah, the plot thickens! This isn’t just a house; it’s a living, breathing chronicle of fortunes, families, and fabulous parties. Let’s dive into the juicy details of how this estate evolved from its humble beginnings as Hutton Manor to the iconic Dina Merrill House we know today.

First up, let’s talk ownership. After Hugh Chisholm envisioned this Gilded Age dream, the estate likely passed through various hands, each adding their unique flavor to the mix. Imagine the whispered deals, the handshakes, and the sheer weight of wealth changing hands! Knowing when and to whom the property transferred provides critical insights into how the estate adapted to changing times and tastes. Picture this as the real-estate version of a high-stakes game of telephone, where each owner’s decisions tweak the message slightly, but the core story remains intact.

Of course, with new owners come new ideas! Over the years, the house underwent significant renovations and alterations. Perhaps a sunroom was added to soak up that sweet Hamptons sunshine, or maybe the kitchens were updated to cater to the culinary whims of a new generation. It is crucial to think about the changing fashions and lifestyles of the successive owners. Which sections of the house were modified to suit them? Were there sections that were expanded or removed? These architectural face-lifts weren’t just cosmetic; they reflect the changing lifestyles and priorities of the families who called it home. Imagine the interior design choices through the decades! From the plush velvets of the Gilded Age to the sleek minimalism of modern times, each renovation tells a story of its own.

Now for the fun part: the anecdotes and stories! Every grand estate has its share of whispers, rumors, and legendary parties. Did a famous artist once paint in the gardens? Was there a scandalous affair that played out within its walls? These behind-the-scenes glimpses bring the house to life, transforming it from a mere structure into a stage for human drama. Perhaps a secret room was discovered during renovations, or maybe a ghost story has been passed down through the generations of staff. These are the tidbits that transform a house history into a compelling narrative. This isn’t just about bricks and mortar; it’s about the lives lived within those walls!

Preserving a Legacy: Landmark Status and Future Prospects

Has anyone ever wondered, what happens to these grand old dames of estates after their time in the spotlight? Well, with a property as historically rich and architecturally significant as the Dina Merrill House, the question of its future naturally arises. One option that often comes up for properties like this is pursuing landmark status or historical preservation. Imagine, a big ol’ plaque proudly proclaiming the house’s importance for generations to come!

But let’s be real, it’s not all sunshine and roses (or perfectly manicured rose gardens, in this case). There are both benefits and challenges to consider. On the plus side, landmark status can offer protection from demolition or insensitive renovations, ensuring the house retains its character. It can also open doors to grants and funding for restoration work – think of it as a little helping hand in keeping this beauty in tip-top shape.

However, it also comes with restrictions. Owners might face limitations on what they can change or add to the property, and navigating the preservation process can be a bureaucratic maze. It’s a bit like agreeing to always wear a tuxedo to a black-tie event – elegant, sure, but not exactly the most comfortable choice for every occasion.

So, what does the future hold for 95 Coopers Neck Lane? Maybe it will continue as a private residence, cherished by new owners who appreciate its history. Perhaps it could be transformed into a museum, offering a glimpse into the glamorous lives of the Huttons, Posts, and Merrills. Or maybe, just maybe, it could become a unique event space, hosting lavish parties and weddings, keeping the spirit of high society alive within its walls.

Who knows? The possibilities are as vast as the estate itself. One thing’s for sure, though: the Dina Merrill House is more than just bricks and mortar. It’s a living testament to a bygone era, a tangible link to the titans of industry, society doyennes, and Hollywood royalty. And whatever its future may be, its legacy will undoubtedly endure.

So, next time you’re driving through Water Mill, keep an eye out for this iconic, albeit now altered, piece of architectural history. It’s a reminder that even the most fabulous homes have their own stories, and sometimes, those stories take unexpected turns!